Hours & Location
182 West Main Street,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
631-636-0500 x 2
bayshore@theherojoint.com
Monday: 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM- 7:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM- 7:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM - 7:00 PM
We are NOW OPEN as of October 1st, 2021!
We are located at the corner of West Main Street and Clinton Avenue. We are directly across the street from St. Patrick's Catholic Church!
Same menu as Patchogue!
Menus
- Breakfast
- Specialty Hot Sandwiches
- Design Your Own
- Cheesesteaks
- Salads
- Sides / Snacks
- Drinks
- Catering Menu
BREAKFAST NOW BEING SERVED DAILY! BOTH LOCATIONS!!!
Build Your Own
-
Egg Style
Scrambled
Fried
-
Cheese
American
Swiss
Provolone
Mozzarella
Pepper Jack
Muenster
Gouda
-
Fillings
Onion
Banana Peppers
Cherry Peppers
Tomatoes
Roasted Red Peppers
Black Olives
Jalapeños
-
Sauces
Ketchup
Hot Sauce
Chipotle Mayo
Mike’s Hot Honey + $1
-
Spices
Salt
Pepper
-
MEAT
+$2 each
Bacon
Ham
Turkey
Roast Beef
Sausage
-
Combo
+ $5
Coffee
Hash Browns
-
Small Hero (2 Eggs)
Your Choice of Plain, Whole Wheat, or Spinach Wraps.
$5
-
Wrap (2 Eggs)
Your Choice of Plain, Whole Wheat, or Spinach Wraps.
$5
-
Large Hero (3 Eggs)
Gluten-Free Bread Available.
$7
Signature Sandwiches
-
Bec Hero
3 Eggs Scrambled or Fried, Bacon, American Cheese on A Hero
$9
-
Spicy Presidente
3 Eggs Scrambled or Fried, Bacon, Cherry Peppers, Chipotle Mayo, Pepper Jack on A Hero
$9
-
Hungryman
3 Eggs Scrambled or Fried, Bacon, Sausage, Ham, American Cheese, with Hash Browns
$11.99
Extras
-
Coffee
Sm $2
Lg $3
-
Hash Browns
$3.99
Specialty Hot Sandwiches
-
The Bird
House-Roasted Turkey, Housemade Cranberry Sauce & Housemade Stuffing on Marbled Sourdough Bread.
$17.99
-
The Piglet
Our Applewood Smoked Carving Ham, Swiss & Gold's Mustard on Whole Grain Bread TOASTED for Melty Deliciousness.
$12.99
-
Chicken Club
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Mayo, Lettuce & Tomato on Sourdough Bread or Hero.
$16.99
-
Daverami on Rye
Our Angus Choice Pastrami Piled High on Rye Bread - Dave Recommends It Straight Up (But Feel Free to add Mustard). Choice of two serving sizes - our regular healthy portion or the massive Overstuffed NYC Style (14 oz.)
Standard Serving $18.99
Overstuffed New York City Style (14 oz.) $28.99
-
Original Reuben
Corned Beef, Swiss, Sauerkraut & Russian Dressing, Piled High on Rye Bread. Choice of two serving sizes - our regular healthy portion or Overstuffed NYC Style (14 oz.)
Standard Serving $16.99
Overstuffed New York City Style (14 oz.) $26.99
-
Mikey Manhattan
Our House-Roasted Roast Beef, Melted Mozzarella, and Gravy on A Toasted Garlic Bread Hero.
$12.99
-
BLT
Applewood Smoked Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato on Toasted Sourdough Bread or a hero.
Small $14.99
-
Chicken Parm Hero
Chicken Cutlets, Our Homemade Marinara Sauce with Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese.
Small $10.99
Large $15.99
-
Meatball Parm Hero
Our Homemade Meatballs, Our Homemade Marinara Sauce with Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese.
Small $10.99
Large $15.99
-
Vegan Burger
Served on A Vegan Bun with Lettuce, Tomato, & Onion.
$12.99
Can You Believe It a Vegan Item!
-
The Harold
This sandwich is a hot mess of deliciousness. It is a true handful, but you love it at the same time. The sandwich is made up of Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Pepper Jack Cheese, Fries, Pickles, Honey Mustard, and BBQ Sauce on a hero.
$18.99
Hope You're Hungry!
-
The Balsamic Bird
Choice of breaded chicken cutlet or grilled chicken with roasted red peppers, mozzarella, and balsamic dressing on a hero.
$14.99
-
The Tuscan
Grilled Chicken, Pesto Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers on a Rosemary Bun. A delicious flavor bomb
$15.99
-
Johnny Chop Cheese
The New York City classic answer to the Philly Cheesesteak. Ground beef, seasoned and sautéed with onion and green peppers covered with American cheese on a hero with mayo and ketchup. A true belly bomber!
$13.99
Signature Cold Sandwiches
-
The Meathead
Traditional "American" style hero done in our higher quality untraditional ways. House Roasted Turkey, Carving Ham, and our House Roasted Cherry Red Roast Beef take you all the way to downtown Flavor Town. Note: We only put meat and cheese on it, but we have a bunch of fun toppings you can add. Just ask!
Small $9.99
Large $14.99
-
The Bro
Salami, Pepperoni, Capicola & Provolone with Your Choice of Fillings.
Small $9.99
Large $14.99
-
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Croutons, Caesar Dressing in Any Type of Wrap.
$15.99
We Offer Gluten-Free Hero Bread.
We Also Offer Plain, Whole Wheat and Spinach Wraps!
Make It a Combo!
Add Signature Potato Chips or Coleslaw & a 16 Oz. Fountain Soda to Any Order - $4
Design Your Own
Small Hero: $9.99 (limit 3 toppers) • Large Hero: $14.99 (limit 4 toppers)
- Meats: House Roasted Turkey, House Roasted Roast Beef, Applewood Smoked Carving Ham, Salami, Perpperoni, Capicola
- Cheeses: Sharp Cheddar, Provolone, American, Swiss, Mozzarella, Pepper Jack
- Toppers: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Banana Peppers, Cherry Peppers, Pickles, Roasted Red Peppers, Sliced Black Olives, Sliced Jalapenos.
- Sauces: Golds Mustard, Mayonnaise, Housemade Chipotle Mayo, Hoseradish, Oil, Red Wine Vinegar
- Specialty Sauces (.50 charge): Bacon Aoli, Mike's Hot Honey.
Meats
-
House-Roasted Turkey
-
House-Roasted Roast Beef
-
Applewood-Smoked Carving Ham
-
Hormel Pepperoni
-
Salami
-
Capicola
-
Bacon
Add
SM $1
LG $2
-
Corned Beef
Add
SM $1
LG $2
-
Pastrami
Add
SM $1
LG $2
-
Grilled Chicken
Add
SM $1
LG $2
-
Chicken Cutlet
SM $1
LG $2
Inclusions
-
Banana Peppers
-
Cherry Peppers
-
Lettuce
-
Onions
-
Pickles
-
Roasted Red Peppers
-
Tomatoes
Cheeses
-
Sharp Cheddar
-
All-Natural Provolone
-
Yellow American
-
Grade A Swiss
-
Fresh Mozzarella
-
Pepper Jack
Included Sauces
-
Gold's Mustard
-
Mayonnaise
-
Chipotle Mayo
-
Horseradish
-
Oil
-
Red Wine Vinegar
Specialty Sauces
$0.50 Each-
Dark Ale Mustard
-
Bacon Aioli
-
-
Give Any Sandwich "The Love"
Salt, Pepper, Oregano, Oil & Red Wine Vinegar
Cheesesteaks
Small $10.99 / Large $14.99
- Cheeses: Cheddar, Provolone, Yellow American, Swiss, Mozzarella, Pepper Jack
- Toppers (Includes 2): Banana Peppers, Cherry Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Roasted Red Peppers
- Sauces: BBQ, Buffalo, Teriyaki, Chipotle Mayo
-
Cheeses
Sharp Cheddar
All-Natural Provolone
Yellow American
Grade A Swiss
Fresh Mozzarella
-
Inclusions
Limit 2. $0.50 for each additional.
Banana Peppers
Cherry Peppers
Mushrooms
Onions
Roasted Red Peppers
Sweet Peppers
-
Included Sauces
Choose 1. $0.50 for each additional.
BBQ
Buffalo
Teriyaki
Chipotle Mayo
-
Specialty Sauces
$0.50 each.
Bacon Aioli
Korean BBQ
Salads
Choose 4 Inclusions & 1 Dressing. $15.99Side Salad 2 Inclusions & 1 Dressing. $10.99
Each Additional Inclusions - $0.50 (Add Grilled Chicken - $2)
-
Base
Mesculin Mix
Romaine
-
Dressings
Creamy Balsamic
Lite Balsamic Vinaigrette
Italian
Russian
Thousand Island
Caesar
Blue Cheese
Ranch
Miso Ginger
-
Inclusions
Bacon Bits
Craisins
Croutons
Cucumbers
Goat Cheese
Gorgonzola Cheese
Mushrooms
Onions
Pecans
Shaved Parmesan Cheese
Tomatoes
Walnuts
-
Roasted Caesar Salad
Signature Salad | Red-Leaf Romaine Lightly Grilled, Topped with Grilled Chicken, Bacon Bites, Shaved Parmesan, Caesar Dressing.
$18.99
-
50/50 Combo
1/2 a Cold Cut Hero & a Side Salad
$15.99
Add Grilled Chicken to A Side Salad $1
Deli Style Salads
Small Container-$2.99 / Large Container-$4.99On a Half Hero or Sandwich-$6.99
On a Large Hero-$10.99
Toppings $0.25 each
-
Chicken Salad
House Roasted and Shredded Chicken, Grapes, Almond, and Spices.
tree nut
-
Tuna Salad
Chunks of Albacore Tuna, Red Onion, Celery, and Spices.
Soups
-
8oz. Cup of Soup
$8.99
-
16oz. Cup of Soup
$10.99
-
Soup & Half Cold Sandwich
$15.99
Sides / Snacks
-
Housemade Potato Chips
Our famous chips made in house. Available flavors include: salt & pepper, salt & vinegar, rosemary & garlic, garlic & parmesan, jalapeno, and ranch chive.
$3.99
-
Flavors
Salt & Pepper
Rosemary & Garlic
Salt & Vinegar
Jalapeño
Ranch Chive
Garlic & Parmesan
-
Coleslaw
Made in house daily.
Small $2
Medium $3.75
Large $6
-
Macaroni Salad
Made in house daily.
Small $2
Medium $3.75
Large $6
-
Classic Shoestring Fries
$3.99
-
Zesty Waffle Fries
$3.99
-
Loaded Potato Skins
Crispy potato skins, covered with melted cheese, scallions, bacon bits, and sour cream.
$9.99
-
Wings
Breaded fried chicken wings tender and juicy. Available with buffalo, sweet chili, garlic parmesan, BBQ, terayaki, or Korean BBQ
6 Wings $13.99
12 Wings $17.99
-
Schweddy Balls
Housemade macaroni and cheese balls mixed with bacon, served with our Siracha Ranch dipping sauce. Of course, you get 2 balls! ;p
$10.99
-
Pretzel Sticks
3 Warm Pretzel Sticks Served with Mustard and our Housemade Ale Beer Cheese dip
$11.99
-
Mozzarella Sticks
6 fried seasoned mozzarella sticks
$11.99
Drinks
We Now Have Beer!
-
Rotating Tap Lines
In Patchogue, we have 2 rotating tap lines. In Bay Shore, we rotate four draft beers.
-
Cans, Cases, and 6 Packs to go!
-
Various 20 oz. Sodas
$2.50
-
Various 2L Sodas
$3.99
-
Iced Teas
-
16oz. Fountain Soda
$2.50
-
24oz. Fountain Soda
$2.75
We have a full range of catering options from platters to heroes by the foot. Share Hero Joint quality with your loved ones. We appreciate the opportunity to feed your families always.
Party Platters
-
Meathead Platter
Classic American-style hero platter featuring our House-Roasted Turkey, House-Roasted Roast Beef, Applewood Smoked Carving Ham, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Salt, Pepper, and Oregano
$8.50 per person
-
Bro Platter
Classic Italian-style hero platter featuring our Salami, Pepperoni, Capicola and Provolone Cheese with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Salt, Pepper, and Oregano
$8.50 per person
Platters
Platters are available with our Meathead & Bro Style sandwiches. Mix and match Meatheads and Bros. Lettuce, Tomato, and Onion can be on the sandwiches or on the side. Also comes with oil & vinegar and mayo on side.-
Meathead
Our Meathead sandwiches cut up.
$8.50 per Per person
-
Bro
Our Bro Sandwiches cut up to share.
$8.50 per Per person
Heroes by the Foot
Traditional deli sandwiches served by the foot anywhere from 2'-6' *Deposits are required on wood boards on the larger heroes. Deposits are returned when our wood is returned to us.-
Meathead
Our Meathead by the foot
$22 per per foot
-
Bro
Our Bro by the foot
$22 per per foot
-
Balsamic Bird
Fried or grilled chicken cutlet, roasted red peppers, and mozzarella cheese. Balsamic dressing served on the side.
$25 per per foot
Sides to Share
Various side dishes to share with our sandwiches-
Bowl of Housemade Chips
A large bowl of any of our chip flavors to share. Salt & Pepper, Salt & Vinegar, Rosemary & Garlic, Garlic Parmesan, Jalapeno, Ranch Chive
$20
-
Bowl of Coleslaw
A large bowl of our housemade coleslaw to share.
$20
-
Bowl of Macaroni Salad
A large bowl of our housemade macaroni salad to share.
$20
Traditional Heroes by the Foot
-
The Meathead
Classic American-style hero featuring our House-Roasted Turkey, House-Roasted Roast Beef, Applewood Smoked Carving Ham, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Salt, Pepper, and Oregano
$22 per foot
-
The Bro
Classic Italian-style hero featuring our Salami, Pepperoni, Capicola and Provolone Cheese with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Salt, Pepper, and Oregano
$22 per foot
-
The Balsamic Bird
Choice of Breaded Chicken Cutlet or Grilled Chicken Cutlet, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, and Balsamic Dressing
$25 per foot
-
Add a pile of our house-made potato chips for an additional $1.00 per person. Available flavors include: Salt & Pepper, Garlic & Parmesan, Garlic & Rosemary, Jalapeno, Salt & Vinegar, and Ranch Chive
Ordering Details:
- Mayo, Oil, & Vinegar can be served on the side.
Please just ask us when booking.
- 50% deposit due at time of order, balance due upon pickup.
- All orders of straight party heroes will require a
refundable deposit for serving board.
- Other special and hot heroes ARE available,
please see an associate.